Durfee Hall is the first stone dormitory constructed on the campus of Yale University. When completed in 1871, it was regarded as a high point in Victorian Gothic style architecture. "It will be a long time before the quiet dignity of its roof and chimneys will be surpassed anywhere." wrote American Architect and Building News. The building facades are predominately split face, New Jersey Sandstone. North River Bluestone and buff colored Ohio Sandstone accentuate the facades at the copings, stringcourses, and ornamental trim. Sandstone turrets flank gables located at each end of the building and massive brick chimneys rise above the slate roofing.
From WJE's condition assessment, a design restoration program was developed that detailed the complete reconstruction of the turrets and chimneys, replacement of the slate roofing and copper flashing, brownstone repairs, and window replacement due to extensive damage caused by years of exposure to harsh New England weather conditions. The project was phased over summer seasons in order for building to remain functional as a dormitory for Yale University.